Recap, with this phrase refers to me.
Recap doesn't like the 8-bit game, he find them as a mere outline of what should be the 16-bit games. I understand that here we enter a question of his personal taste.
For me, Batman is one of the best games I've had on NES, comparable to Natsume's KAGE (Blue Shadow), for those aspects that you've commented in your article and others. But unfortunately I could not make it run at its native resolution with virtuanes097e. A problem, which undoubtedly, have to solve soon.
Anyway, Recap also says that I'm not interested in games that he recommend to me, and that's not entirely true at all.